🚚 Free Worldwide Shipping on All Orders!Shop Now

Home Shop Cart Account

Coins & Currency

Antiques & Collectibles

Store

U.S. Small Cents

Treasure Hunter

Store About Us Contact Us FAQ

© 2026 Treasure Hunter. All rights reserved.

U.S. Small Cents | Treasure Hunter

...

-65%NEW

1859 Indian Head Penny - Choose by Grade / Condition - First year made - 1859 Indian Head Cent 1859

$16.20

$5.67

NEW

1863 Indian Head Penny - Choose by Grade / Condition - Early Date - Civil War Era Cent - 1863 Indian Cent 1863

$6.30

NEW

1874 Indian Head Penny - Choose by Condition / Grade - Great Date; perfect for collections- 1874 Cent

$6.30

NEW

1869 Indian Head Cent - Cull Grade (Worn) - Key Date, Rarest of the 1860's - 1869 Penny Indian Head Penny 1869

$48.00

-65%NEW

1875 Indian Head Penny - VG-XF (Very Good to Extremely Fine) Choose by Grade - Semi-Key Date - Indian Head Cent 1875 - Indian Head Pennies

$16.00

$5.60

-65%NEW

1871 Indian Head Penny - Hard to find Date - Choose by Grade / Condition - Key Date Indian Head - 1871 Indian Head Cent 1871

$60.30

$21.10

-65%NEW

1864 Indian Head Penny - Choose by Grade F-XF (Fine to Extremely Fine) -Civil War Era Coin - Indian Head Cent 1864 Cent - Bronze, No L

$7.00

$2.45

-65%NEW

1870 Indian Head Penny - Key Date Indian Head - Choose by Grade - 1870 US 1 Cent 1870 Indian Head Cent 1870

$19.00

$6.65

-65%NEW

1865 Indian Head Penny - Choose by Grade - Civil War Era Coin - 1865 Cent US One Cent 1865 Indian Head Cent - Early Date

$5.00

$1.75

-65%NEW

1866 Indian Head Penny - AG (About Good) Grade / Condition - Key Date - Indian Head Cent 1866 US One Cent - Tougher Date to Find

$37.00

$12.95

-65%NEW

1863 Indian Head Penny - Cull Condition, Corrosion / Damage Coin - Early Date - Civil War Era Cent - 1863 Indian Head Cent 1863 - Low Grade

$11.00

$3.85

-65%NEW

1868 Indian Head Penny - Choose by Grade / Condition, Choose by Grade - Rarer Date - Civil War Era Coin - 1868 Cent

$8.10

$2.83